Asked by: Estiben Lutzenkirchen
Asked in category: religion and spirituality, christianity
Last Updated: 30th Apr 2024
Are religious confessions admissible as evidence?
New York state law says that confessions and confidences given to clergymen or ministers are protected and cannot be used to support evidence. This privilege does not apply to communications with particular priests or congregants, nor is it limited to confessions made "under the cloak" of confession.
Many people also wonder if religious confessions are admissible in court.
A pastor is generally exempted from the requirement to testify in court or to law enforcement about matters discussed in confessions. However, court can challenge the so-called priest penitent privilege. The limits of the privilege to confess in church are revealed by cases challenging it.
Second, can a priest tell you if someone has killed you? The priest will not tell anyone if you confessed to the priest that someone had killed you. This is a very important point for the Catholic church. There is no exception.
People often ask if a priest can give confessions to the police.
Yes, priests can't tell anyone about confessions they have heard. Yes, it is against Catholic faith. The priest can only require penitents to surrender to authorities. If the penitent refuses, he/she may withhold absolution. The Sacramental Seal of Inviolability is not available.
Is confession always kept secret?
However, the Supreme Court of the State ruled in 2016 that any communication to a priest in private in the sacrament confession for the purpose confession, repentance or absolution is confidential.
17 Related Question Answers Found
What happens when you confess to a crime?
Confessing to the police is not a legal conviction. It can GET you a conviction, but only by you appearing in front of a judge and pleading guilty to him as well. The confession by itself has little legal standing until a judge hears it and agrees that it is an honest confession to a crime that you committed.
What happens if you confess you murdered someone to a priest?
TIL that if you confess you murdered someone to a priest, your secret is protected by Catholic law. Actually no, Canon law forbids this. The priest can only recommend you turn yourself in to clear your own conscience, but it cannot be a part of your penance.
When can the seal of confession be broken?
Punishment for breaking the seal of the confessional is conferred by the severity of the violation: "a person who violate directly violates the seal of the confessional (that is: explicitly connects a sin to a penitent) incurs a latae sententiae excommunication." One who breaks the seal "indirectly" (that is: through
Can a priest confess to himself?
No, a priest cannot absolve himself of his own sins. The mandate to forgive sins is given to the priest (as it was to the Apostles) not for their own benefit, but for the good of the Church. They too, must humble themselves to confess their sins to receive absolution.
Who do priests confess to?
A bishop, priest, or deacon will confess at the Holy Table (Altar) where the Gospel Book and blessing cross are normally kept. He confesses in the same manner as a layman, except that when a priest hears a bishop's confession, the priest kneels.
What are the requirements for establishing the clergy penitent privilege?
In states that have a clergy privilege, an ordained minister, priest, rabbi or other leader of an established church or religious organization is required to testify in a proceeding concerning anything that the penitent said which would be considered confidential in the religious leader's professional capacity and when
When should you go to confession?
According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, each faithful of right discerning age is “bound by an obligation faithfully to confess serious sins at least once a year.” (CCC 1457) Some might be tempted to just do the minimum. The Church allows it at one per year after all.
Can non Catholics go to confession?
Clerics invite non-Roman Catholics to come to confessional to 'say what's on their heart', as part of initiative launched by Pope Francis. Unlike confession itself – which, as one of the Church's sacraments is only open to Catholics – they will not have to go through formal steps of expressing penitence for their sins.
Can sins be forgiven without confession?
Non-Catholics, however often ask whether they can confess their sins directly to God, and whether God can forgive them without going through a priest. Those who commit mortal, or serious, sins like adultery and murder should not receive Communion without first going to confession.
What is the confession room called?
A confessional is a box, cabinet, or stall in which the priest in some Christian churches sits to hear the confessions of penitents. It is the usual venue for the sacrament in the Roman Catholic Church and the Lutheran Churches, but similar structures are also used in Anglican churches of an Anglo-Catholic orientation.
What is Confession called now?
The Sacrament of Penance (also commonly called the Sacrament of Reconciliation or Confession) is one of the seven sacraments of the Catholic Church (known in Eastern Christianity as sacred mysteries), in which the faithful are absolved from sins committed after Baptism and they are reconciled with the Christian
Do other religions have confession?
In modern times the Roman Catholic Church teaches that penance is a sacrament, instituted by Christ, in which a confession of all serious sins committed after Baptism is necessary. The doctrine of the Eastern Orthodox churches concerning confession agrees with that of the Roman Catholic Church.
Can you talk to a priest about anything?
Any person is free to approach a priest to talk, discuss life issues, etc with “conversion” being absolutely NO precondition. But realise… while most priests have some background in psychology, counseling, marriage and family issues, we are not psychologists nor marriage counselors nor therapists.
Can a priest attend a non Catholic wedding?
Barr added that priests can also request to marry a couple in a non-church wedding, as long as one is a confirmed Catholic and resides in the Archdiocese of Baltimore. They also have to go through the Church's marriage preparation.
What is absolution in the Catholic Church?
Absolution is a traditional theological term for the forgiveness experienced by Christians in the life of the Church. Some traditions see absolution as a sacrament (the Sacrament of Penance), a concept found in the Roman Catholic Church, Eastern Catholic Churches, and Eastern Orthodox churches.
Do priests remember confessions?
No, in the sense that it's totally possible for a priest to remember a sin from confession, though he can't talk about it (at the pain of being instantly excommunicated by the very act of sharing). The confessional isn't “magic”, though sometimes it seems God does give some priests some supernatural forgetfulness.
How do priests decide penance?
The priest must be willing to endure prison, torture, and death before violating the Seal of Confession, the secrecy of the sacrament. Contrition: You must be sorry you committed the sins and resolve to do your best not to repeat them. Penance: After you confess your sins, the priest gives you a penance to perform.
Similar Asks
Trending Questions
Co-authors
4
Updated On
30th Apr 2024
Views
863
48
Questions
21
Answers
2
Videos
17
Users
95% of readers found this page helpful.
4.1/5
Rate this post by clicking on a star above
Thank you for your vote!